Morteza Makki – European Affairs Expert
As long as Joe Biden was in the White House, there were no fundamental differences between Europe and the United States in dealing with Russia. Both sides emphasized the approach of responding by imposing economic sanctions on Russia on one hand, and providing extensive financial and military aid to Ukraine on the other. They sought, through this, to bring Russia to its knees, both militarily and economically. However, with Donald Trump’s entry into the White House, the political equations in Brussels-Washington relations were deeply fractured. Unlike the Democrats, Trump believed that Russia’s attack on Ukraine was more of a challenge for Europe than a problem for the United States. With this perspective, he sought to end the Russia-Ukraine war within 24 hours. But Trump’s wish and dream did not materialize. Therefore, the U.S. president tried to achieve a framework for peace and reconciliation in Ukraine through extensive negotiations and bilateral engagements with Russian officials. In this endeavor, Trump essentially placed Putin’s agenda for Ukraine on the negotiation table to encourage and persuade Russia to agree to a ceasefire. But the Russians had maximal demands regarding the Ukraine war, and at the same time, there was a deep rift between Europe and the U.S. on one side, and the U.S. and Ukraine on the other, over how to deal with Russia.
Trump demanded that Ukraine make concessions to Russia and cede part of its territory in exchange for peace. But neither Ukraine nor its European allies agreed to this demand. In practice, Trump concluded that without the cooperation and alignment of Ukraine and Europe, and by ignoring the role of these two actors in a war that has now lasted for more than three years, he could not achieve his desired peace and reconciliation solely through a bilateral approach with Putin. Trump’s latest political move regarding Ukraine was meeting with Vladimir Putin in Alaska. The outcome of this meeting was largely contingent on U.S. negotiations with Ukraine and European governments.
Three days after the meeting between Putin and Trump in Alaska, the U.S. president met with Volodymyr Zelenskyy and several European leaders at the White House, and these countries opposed any territorial concessions in exchange for peace with Putin. Effectively, the summits between the U.S. and Russia in Alaska and between the U.S. and Europe in Washington yielded no results regarding how to end the Ukraine war. European governments, in numerous meetings held at various levels, assessed that providing financial and military aid to Ukraine was the only way to pressure Russia to end the war.
Amidst this, Trump also tried, through repeatedly threatening Russia and imposing economic sanctions and providing military aid to Ukraine (albeit with European governments’ money), to somehow align with European capitals in pressuring Russia. But unlike before, Trump made military aid to Ukraine conditional on European governments covering its costs. At the same time, a serious difference of opinion emerged between Europe and the U.S. regarding the issue of economic sanctions against Russia; Trump constantly criticized European governments, asking how they could want to put economic pressure on Russia while still receiving gas from it.
Trump demanded that European governments, instead of buying gas from Russia, supply the gas they need from the United States, so that they could both cover the costs of the Ukraine war this way and also seriously subject Russia to economic sanctions. Although European governments have set a schedule to reduce Russian gas purchases to zero, there is no consensus among them on this. Some European governments, such as Slovakia and Hungary, demand the continued purchase of oil and gas from Russia and consider alternative energy supply routes to be very expensive. Furthermore, these governments have different approaches to the European Union’s stance on Russia and believe that this mode of European political action towards Moscow will not yield results, and that the ultimate losers of this war will be Ukraine and the European Union.
This line of thinking exists in some other European governments as well, but they do not explicitly announce it. Meanwhile, Eastern European countries like Poland still demand the intensification of military, economic, and political policies against the Kremlin.
Ultimately, the scenario of sanctions, economic pressure on Russia, and increased financial and military aid to Ukraine has so far yielded no results on the ground for Kyiv. On the contrary, Russia, by intensifying military attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure, including power plants, and flying drones over EU member states, has created a deep political and military challenge both among EU members and also raised concerns among European members regarding America’s commitment to supporting European governments against Russian military threats.
The Americans have so far tried to overlook the intensification of Russian military attacks in Ukraine and the flight of Russian drones over EU member states, and not consider this issue as a serious threat among NATO members. Because they well know that any reaction to these actions will entail serious costs for Washington. In reality, the movements and developments in the political and military arena of the Ukraine war indicate that this nearly four-year-old crisis still has a vague outlook and will remain the European Union’s most significant political and security challenge in the coming years.
U.S.-Europe Differences Regarding the Ukraine War

LATEST CONTENT
The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran
SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.
A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting
SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.
From the “Makkah Pact” to “Collective Security”; a Historic Opportunity for West Asia
SCFR Online – Opinion: The presence of high-ranking delegations from the member states of the “Makkah Joint Defense Agreement” in Tehran, at a time when the region is embroiled in military tensions and the fragile process of Iran-US negotiations, is considered a turning point in the security equations of the Persian Gulf and West Asia.
The Non-impact of the Israeli Regime’s Elections on the Strategy of the Axis of Resistance
SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the Israeli regime’s elections can affect the composition of this regime’s cabinet and the manner of implementing its aggressive plans, but internal political changes do not necessarily lead to a strategic transformation in its approach to Palestine, Iran, and the Axis of Resistance.
Últimas publicaciones
The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran
SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.
A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting
SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.
From the “Makkah Pact” to “Collective Security”; a Historic Opportunity for West Asia
SCFR Online – Opinion: The presence of high-ranking delegations from the member states of the “Makkah Joint Defense Agreement” in Tehran, at a time when the region is embroiled in military tensions and the fragile process of Iran-US negotiations, is considered a turning point in the security equations of the Persian Gulf and West Asia.
The Non-impact of the Israeli Regime’s Elections on the Strategy of the Axis of Resistance
SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the Israeli regime’s elections can affect the composition of this regime’s cabinet and the manner of implementing its aggressive plans, but internal political changes do not necessarily lead to a strategic transformation in its approach to Palestine, Iran, and the Axis of Resistance.
DERNIER CONTENU
The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran
SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.
A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting
SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.
From the “Makkah Pact” to “Collective Security”; a Historic Opportunity for West Asia
SCFR Online – Opinion: The presence of high-ranking delegations from the member states of the “Makkah Joint Defense Agreement” in Tehran, at a time when the region is embroiled in military tensions and the fragile process of Iran-US negotiations, is considered a turning point in the security equations of the Persian Gulf and West Asia.
The Non-impact of the Israeli Regime’s Elections on the Strategy of the Axis of Resistance
SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the Israeli regime’s elections can affect the composition of this regime’s cabinet and the manner of implementing its aggressive plans, but internal political changes do not necessarily lead to a strategic transformation in its approach to Palestine, Iran, and the Axis of Resistance.
DERNIER CONTENU
The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran
SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.
A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting
SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.
From the “Makkah Pact” to “Collective Security”; a Historic Opportunity for West Asia
SCFR Online – Opinion: The presence of high-ranking delegations from the member states of the “Makkah Joint Defense Agreement” in Tehran, at a time when the region is embroiled in military tensions and the fragile process of Iran-US negotiations, is considered a turning point in the security equations of the Persian Gulf and West Asia.
The Non-impact of the Israeli Regime’s Elections on the Strategy of the Axis of Resistance
SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the Israeli regime’s elections can affect the composition of this regime’s cabinet and the manner of implementing its aggressive plans, but internal political changes do not necessarily lead to a strategic transformation in its approach to Palestine, Iran, and the Axis of Resistance.
DERNIER CONTENU
The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran
SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.
A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting
SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.
From the “Makkah Pact” to “Collective Security”; a Historic Opportunity for West Asia
SCFR Online – Opinion: The presence of high-ranking delegations from the member states of the “Makkah Joint Defense Agreement” in Tehran, at a time when the region is embroiled in military tensions and the fragile process of Iran-US negotiations, is considered a turning point in the security equations of the Persian Gulf and West Asia.
The Non-impact of the Israeli Regime’s Elections on the Strategy of the Axis of Resistance
SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the Israeli regime’s elections can affect the composition of this regime’s cabinet and the manner of implementing its aggressive plans, but internal political changes do not necessarily lead to a strategic transformation in its approach to Palestine, Iran, and the Axis of Resistance.
0 Comments