Sabotage in Natanz Nuclear Facilities and the Question of Deterrence

Strategic Council Online - A faculty member of the Institute for Strategic Studies, says that preventing enhancement of capabilities that could create deterrence against Israel’s capabilities and bring Israel’s deterrence under question is the regime’s consistent policy. He added: If strategic patience is interpreted as not responding, there may be more damage to Iran’s national interests and security.

Mehdi Shapouri, speaking in an interview with the website of the Strategic Council on Foreign Relations, said that the sabotage in Natanz facilities, under the current situation, should be investigated in connection with the ongoing negotiations for the revival of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). He noted: The Zionist regime wants pressure and sanctions against Iran to remain and officials of the regime have repeatedly stated that they are opposed to the revival of the JCPOA, lifting or easing of sanctions against Iran, and that conditions should not be created for Iran to be relieved of the existing pressures; therefore, they seek to disrupt the ongoing negotiations to revive the JCPOA.

He added: Of course, in the past one year, other measures have been taken against Iran’s nuclear program, including explosion that occurred in Natanz in July 2020 and also assassination of Fakhrizadeh (nuclear scientist); which is believed that those cases have also been committed by Israel. This shows that beyond the negotiations related to the revival of JCPOA, the Zionist regime is trying to prevent Iran’s progress, especially in the nuclear issue.

Shapouri explained: This issue can be analyzed from two points of view; one is that the Zionist regime sees the Islamic Republic of Iran as an existential threat to itself and, therefore, sees Iran’s acquisition of some military and nuclear capabilities as a threat to its survival. Second, it is a continuation of the regime’s enduring policy of undermining the nuclear capabilities of countries in the region, especially rival and enemy powers; because according to the Zionist authorities, such capabilities can change the balance of power and deterrence. Israel has done the same in the past in Iraq and Syria.

Preventing strengthening of Iran’s deterrence; consistent policy of the Zionist regime and the US

Referring to the US involvement with Israel in some subversive actions, including spread of the Stuxnet virus at Iran’s nuclear facilities, the expert on strategic affairs added: Preventing the strengthening of capabilities that could deter Israel’s capabilities and bring Israel’s deterrence under question is the constant policy of this regime. At the same time, this is in line with the US policies and interests regarding the Islamic Republic of Iran. In the Biden administration’s interim national security document which has been released recently, it has been stated: Regional players such as Iran and North Korea continue to pursue game changer capabilities and technologies; while threatening the US allies and partners and challenging regional stability.

He said: Therefore, the United States and Israel are either involved in such actions against Iran’s nuclear and military facilities, or they are aware of each other’s actions.

Global reactions to the attack on Natanz facilities

Referring to the global reactions to the attack on Natanz facilities, he continued: Some countries may condemn the blow on the Iranian nuclear facilities in their stated positions, but it should be borne in mind that some countries both in the region and globally, finally are satisfied with such events; because this will reduce the capacity or speed of Iran’s nuclear activities. However, despite Iran’s consistent policy and its repeated emphasis on the peaceful nature of its nuclear activities, it is viewed within the context of nuclear proliferation discussions, influenced by the atmosphere of security and imaging of Iran’s nuclear program by the enemies.

Shapouri, saying that in the discussion of nuclear proliferation, the international community is the source of security, so the response to the threat is global and international, added: In fact, placing the threat of Iran’s nuclear program as a threat to the international community increases the legitimacy of action against it and reduces the cost of action against it. This is a very important issue that the Islamic Republic of Iran must take seriously and not allow the nuclear program to be presented as a threat to international peace.

Concept of “strategic patience” against the enemy

The expert on international affairs further referred to the policy known as the “strategic patience” and noted that this concept did not exist in the official policy of Iran, saying: This concept does not mean that no measure should be taken against the actions of the rivals and enemies, but, it is aimed at not giving the answer that the enemy wants; rather, give an answer that, while creating deterrence against the enemy, does not have negative consequences for our own interests. In fact, it is important to balance the benefits and costs of action.

Shapouri explained: The meaning of strategic patience in relation to Israel and even the United States is that the response to their actions will be based on the time and place determined by the Islamic Republic of Iran and not within the framework they provide. In fact, the problem is not to fall into the trap of the other side. At the same time, it must be noted that the response to the actions of the enemy must be appropriate. If they took covert action, the proportionate response of the Islamic Republic must also be in the realm of covert action and, conversely, if they took open action, the Islamic Republic must also take overt action; like a missile attack on the Ain al-Assad base in retaliation for the assassination of Sardar Soleimani.

Lack of reciprocal response causes failure of deterrence

Saying that based on the logic of responding appropriately to the enemy’s covert action, Iran may have responded to many covert actions against itself, he added: If we interpret strategic patience as not responding, there may be significant damage to national interests and security of Iran; because it means that there is no cost to the other party’s actions and it can intensify such measures. In the deterrent literature, this can even lead to war. In fact, one of the reasons for the failure of deterrence is the appeasement against actions of a rival or enemy.

60% enrichment; a strategic response to enemy action and a powerful tool for diplomacy

Referring to Iran’s decision to carry out 60% enrichment, Shapouri called it a response to the sabotage in Natanz and said: If that measure had not been taken, I do not know that whether 60% enrichment would have been put on the agenda in the current situation. Indeed, this level of enrichment was one of Iran’s responses to the sabotage at Natanz, and it emphasizes that attempts to deal a strike on Iran’s nuclear facilities not only will not stop Iran’s activities, but that Iran can pursue its nuclear activities at higher levels.

According to Shapouri; in the current context of negotiations to revive the JCPOA, this also means that sabotage of nuclear facilities not only cannot empty Iran’s hand in the negotiations, but also puts Iran at a higher level of bargaining.

The expert on international affairs stressed that in the discussion of turning capabilities into advantages in nuclear diplomacy, as well as in the overall discussion of Iran’s power, 60% enrichment by informing the IAEA could bring good results in the national interest; provided that care is taken that the enemy does not turn this action into further pressure on Iran. Here it is the art of diplomacy that can work. He continued: we should try to turn those capacities into privilege for the country with the tool of diplomacy.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST CONTENT

Europe’s Enduring Dependence on Persian Gulf Energy

SCFR Online – Opinion: The dominant discourse in the field of European energy security over the past two decades has revolved around diversification of supply sources and the gradual reduction of dependence on fossil fuels. This narrative, which gained particular momentum after the Ukraine gas crisis in 2006 and its intensification in 2014 and 2022, was based on the assumption that Europe could free itself from the geopolitical vulnerabilities arising from dependence on specific suppliers through investment in renewable energy, imports of liquefied natural gas from diversified sources, and the establishment of new infrastructure. However, a closer analysis of energy trade data and the structure of the global oil and gas supply chain presents a different picture. Europe has not only failed to meaningfully reduce its dependence on the Persian Gulf, but in some sectors — particularly in liquefied natural gas imports — this dependence has deepened. This reality, which is often overlooked in public discourse, raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of Europe’s energy security strategies and their impact on regional power equations.

The Challenge of Hezbollah’s Low-Cost “FPV” Drones for the Zionist Regime

SCFR Online – Opinion: In modern warfare, it has always been assumed that the more expensive, and advanced the weapon—particularly from well-known companies—the more certain the victory will be. However, developments on the northern front of occupied Palestine in recent months have challenged this long-held belief. Here, the Zionist regime’s military, despite possessing the most advanced defense systems such as Iron Dome, David’s Sling, and Arrow, as well as fifth-generation F-35 fighter jets, Merkava tanks, and other modern equipment found in few countries worldwide, has effectively been rendered helpless against Hezbollah Lebanon’s few-hundred-dollar drones. Benjamin Netanyahu’s bitter admission regarding the inability to counter this threat, and his order to allocate an unlimited budget to find a solution, underscores the reality that the era of pure superiority through expensive technologies has come to an end.

The Impact of West Asian Developments on the Ukraine War

SCFR Online – Note: Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, recently announced—more than four years after the commencement of military aggression against Ukraine—that he believes the conflict between Russia and Ukraine is drawing to a close.

Temporary China–U.S. Trade Truce in the Shadow of Fundamental Distrust

SCFR Online – Opinion: The recent visit of the President of the United States to China is significant from various aspects; because China is recognized as the world’s second-largest economic power and a growing economy. The Chinese are also advancing in various fields, including the space sector, artificial intelligence, and military industries; to the extent that in the military sector, whereas they previously lacked an aircraft carrier, they now possess their third aircraft carrier. On the other hand, the United States, as a superpower, has always regarded China as its rival and continues to view it as such today.

Loading

Últimas publicaciones

Europe’s Enduring Dependence on Persian Gulf Energy

SCFR Online – Opinion: The dominant discourse in the field of European energy security over the past two decades has revolved around diversification of supply sources and the gradual reduction of dependence on fossil fuels. This narrative, which gained particular momentum after the Ukraine gas crisis in 2006 and its intensification in 2014 and 2022, was based on the assumption that Europe could free itself from the geopolitical vulnerabilities arising from dependence on specific suppliers through investment in renewable energy, imports of liquefied natural gas from diversified sources, and the establishment of new infrastructure. However, a closer analysis of energy trade data and the structure of the global oil and gas supply chain presents a different picture. Europe has not only failed to meaningfully reduce its dependence on the Persian Gulf, but in some sectors — particularly in liquefied natural gas imports — this dependence has deepened. This reality, which is often overlooked in public discourse, raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of Europe’s energy security strategies and their impact on regional power equations.

The Challenge of Hezbollah’s Low-Cost “FPV” Drones for the Zionist Regime

SCFR Online – Opinion: In modern warfare, it has always been assumed that the more expensive, and advanced the weapon—particularly from well-known companies—the more certain the victory will be. However, developments on the northern front of occupied Palestine in recent months have challenged this long-held belief. Here, the Zionist regime’s military, despite possessing the most advanced defense systems such as Iron Dome, David’s Sling, and Arrow, as well as fifth-generation F-35 fighter jets, Merkava tanks, and other modern equipment found in few countries worldwide, has effectively been rendered helpless against Hezbollah Lebanon’s few-hundred-dollar drones. Benjamin Netanyahu’s bitter admission regarding the inability to counter this threat, and his order to allocate an unlimited budget to find a solution, underscores the reality that the era of pure superiority through expensive technologies has come to an end.

The Impact of West Asian Developments on the Ukraine War

SCFR Online – Note: Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, recently announced—more than four years after the commencement of military aggression against Ukraine—that he believes the conflict between Russia and Ukraine is drawing to a close.

Temporary China–U.S. Trade Truce in the Shadow of Fundamental Distrust

SCFR Online – Opinion: The recent visit of the President of the United States to China is significant from various aspects; because China is recognized as the world’s second-largest economic power and a growing economy. The Chinese are also advancing in various fields, including the space sector, artificial intelligence, and military industries; to the extent that in the military sector, whereas they previously lacked an aircraft carrier, they now possess their third aircraft carrier. On the other hand, the United States, as a superpower, has always regarded China as its rival and continues to view it as such today.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

Europe’s Enduring Dependence on Persian Gulf Energy

SCFR Online – Opinion: The dominant discourse in the field of European energy security over the past two decades has revolved around diversification of supply sources and the gradual reduction of dependence on fossil fuels. This narrative, which gained particular momentum after the Ukraine gas crisis in 2006 and its intensification in 2014 and 2022, was based on the assumption that Europe could free itself from the geopolitical vulnerabilities arising from dependence on specific suppliers through investment in renewable energy, imports of liquefied natural gas from diversified sources, and the establishment of new infrastructure. However, a closer analysis of energy trade data and the structure of the global oil and gas supply chain presents a different picture. Europe has not only failed to meaningfully reduce its dependence on the Persian Gulf, but in some sectors — particularly in liquefied natural gas imports — this dependence has deepened. This reality, which is often overlooked in public discourse, raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of Europe’s energy security strategies and their impact on regional power equations.

The Challenge of Hezbollah’s Low-Cost “FPV” Drones for the Zionist Regime

SCFR Online – Opinion: In modern warfare, it has always been assumed that the more expensive, and advanced the weapon—particularly from well-known companies—the more certain the victory will be. However, developments on the northern front of occupied Palestine in recent months have challenged this long-held belief. Here, the Zionist regime’s military, despite possessing the most advanced defense systems such as Iron Dome, David’s Sling, and Arrow, as well as fifth-generation F-35 fighter jets, Merkava tanks, and other modern equipment found in few countries worldwide, has effectively been rendered helpless against Hezbollah Lebanon’s few-hundred-dollar drones. Benjamin Netanyahu’s bitter admission regarding the inability to counter this threat, and his order to allocate an unlimited budget to find a solution, underscores the reality that the era of pure superiority through expensive technologies has come to an end.

The Impact of West Asian Developments on the Ukraine War

SCFR Online – Note: Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, recently announced—more than four years after the commencement of military aggression against Ukraine—that he believes the conflict between Russia and Ukraine is drawing to a close.

Temporary China–U.S. Trade Truce in the Shadow of Fundamental Distrust

SCFR Online – Opinion: The recent visit of the President of the United States to China is significant from various aspects; because China is recognized as the world’s second-largest economic power and a growing economy. The Chinese are also advancing in various fields, including the space sector, artificial intelligence, and military industries; to the extent that in the military sector, whereas they previously lacked an aircraft carrier, they now possess their third aircraft carrier. On the other hand, the United States, as a superpower, has always regarded China as its rival and continues to view it as such today.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

Europe’s Enduring Dependence on Persian Gulf Energy

SCFR Online – Opinion: The dominant discourse in the field of European energy security over the past two decades has revolved around diversification of supply sources and the gradual reduction of dependence on fossil fuels. This narrative, which gained particular momentum after the Ukraine gas crisis in 2006 and its intensification in 2014 and 2022, was based on the assumption that Europe could free itself from the geopolitical vulnerabilities arising from dependence on specific suppliers through investment in renewable energy, imports of liquefied natural gas from diversified sources, and the establishment of new infrastructure. However, a closer analysis of energy trade data and the structure of the global oil and gas supply chain presents a different picture. Europe has not only failed to meaningfully reduce its dependence on the Persian Gulf, but in some sectors — particularly in liquefied natural gas imports — this dependence has deepened. This reality, which is often overlooked in public discourse, raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of Europe’s energy security strategies and their impact on regional power equations.

The Challenge of Hezbollah’s Low-Cost “FPV” Drones for the Zionist Regime

SCFR Online – Opinion: In modern warfare, it has always been assumed that the more expensive, and advanced the weapon—particularly from well-known companies—the more certain the victory will be. However, developments on the northern front of occupied Palestine in recent months have challenged this long-held belief. Here, the Zionist regime’s military, despite possessing the most advanced defense systems such as Iron Dome, David’s Sling, and Arrow, as well as fifth-generation F-35 fighter jets, Merkava tanks, and other modern equipment found in few countries worldwide, has effectively been rendered helpless against Hezbollah Lebanon’s few-hundred-dollar drones. Benjamin Netanyahu’s bitter admission regarding the inability to counter this threat, and his order to allocate an unlimited budget to find a solution, underscores the reality that the era of pure superiority through expensive technologies has come to an end.

The Impact of West Asian Developments on the Ukraine War

SCFR Online – Note: Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, recently announced—more than four years after the commencement of military aggression against Ukraine—that he believes the conflict between Russia and Ukraine is drawing to a close.

Temporary China–U.S. Trade Truce in the Shadow of Fundamental Distrust

SCFR Online – Opinion: The recent visit of the President of the United States to China is significant from various aspects; because China is recognized as the world’s second-largest economic power and a growing economy. The Chinese are also advancing in various fields, including the space sector, artificial intelligence, and military industries; to the extent that in the military sector, whereas they previously lacked an aircraft carrier, they now possess their third aircraft carrier. On the other hand, the United States, as a superpower, has always regarded China as its rival and continues to view it as such today.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

Europe’s Enduring Dependence on Persian Gulf Energy

SCFR Online – Opinion: The dominant discourse in the field of European energy security over the past two decades has revolved around diversification of supply sources and the gradual reduction of dependence on fossil fuels. This narrative, which gained particular momentum after the Ukraine gas crisis in 2006 and its intensification in 2014 and 2022, was based on the assumption that Europe could free itself from the geopolitical vulnerabilities arising from dependence on specific suppliers through investment in renewable energy, imports of liquefied natural gas from diversified sources, and the establishment of new infrastructure. However, a closer analysis of energy trade data and the structure of the global oil and gas supply chain presents a different picture. Europe has not only failed to meaningfully reduce its dependence on the Persian Gulf, but in some sectors — particularly in liquefied natural gas imports — this dependence has deepened. This reality, which is often overlooked in public discourse, raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of Europe’s energy security strategies and their impact on regional power equations.

The Challenge of Hezbollah’s Low-Cost “FPV” Drones for the Zionist Regime

SCFR Online – Opinion: In modern warfare, it has always been assumed that the more expensive, and advanced the weapon—particularly from well-known companies—the more certain the victory will be. However, developments on the northern front of occupied Palestine in recent months have challenged this long-held belief. Here, the Zionist regime’s military, despite possessing the most advanced defense systems such as Iron Dome, David’s Sling, and Arrow, as well as fifth-generation F-35 fighter jets, Merkava tanks, and other modern equipment found in few countries worldwide, has effectively been rendered helpless against Hezbollah Lebanon’s few-hundred-dollar drones. Benjamin Netanyahu’s bitter admission regarding the inability to counter this threat, and his order to allocate an unlimited budget to find a solution, underscores the reality that the era of pure superiority through expensive technologies has come to an end.

The Impact of West Asian Developments on the Ukraine War

SCFR Online – Note: Vladimir Putin, President of Russia, recently announced—more than four years after the commencement of military aggression against Ukraine—that he believes the conflict between Russia and Ukraine is drawing to a close.

Temporary China–U.S. Trade Truce in the Shadow of Fundamental Distrust

SCFR Online – Opinion: The recent visit of the President of the United States to China is significant from various aspects; because China is recognized as the world’s second-largest economic power and a growing economy. The Chinese are also advancing in various fields, including the space sector, artificial intelligence, and military industries; to the extent that in the military sector, whereas they previously lacked an aircraft carrier, they now possess their third aircraft carrier. On the other hand, the United States, as a superpower, has always regarded China as its rival and continues to view it as such today.

Loading