Need to Resolve Misunderstandings in Iran-Afghanistan Relations

2020/06/21 | Note, Politics, Top News

Strategic Council Online - Although some people are trying to fish in troubled waters by provoking some foreign countries as these people organized protests, albeit limited, in front of the Iranian embassy in Kabul, but there is no doubt that there are problems with the status of Afghan citizens in Iran, something that cannot be denied. Therefore, these problems must be resolved as soon as possible and their traffic to Iran must be legalized. Pir Mohammad Molazehi - Afghanistan Affairs Expert

Over the past month or two, two incidents between Iran and Afghanistan have led to tensions in relations between the two sides, with Tehran and Kabul each narrating their own stories. First, the issue of several Afghan nationals drowned in the Harirod River on May 1. Afghans claimed that Iranian forces had arrested the Afghans who had crossed the river illegally to enter Iran and after being beaten they had been thrown into the river?!

Following this incident, some Afghan officials made some statements which were widely covered by the foreign media. However, the Iranian side completely denied such a narration and it was said that such a thing did not happen in that region. In fact, Iran insists that this happened in an area under  the control of the Afghans and the Afghan side claims that this happened to Afghan nationals in an area controlled by Iranian forces.

Therefore, it was decided to form a joint committee to investigate the issue; But the joint committee also failed to reach a conclusion, and Iran and Afghanistan continue to insist on their own stands.

The second issue was what happened in Yazd; In this case, although the military forces fired on the vehicle carrying Afghans with the intention of stopping it, they blamed the overturning of the car on the driver’s attempt to escape, not the officers’ shooting. In fact, the story was that a car smuggled Afghan workers into Iran from the border. On Wednesday, June 3, the vehicle carrying illegal Afghan national and was being chased by Yazd police force, was targeted by officers in order to stop it.

The incident provoked strong reactions in Afghanistan, especially from the media, which are somehow opposed to Iran and has the financial support of Western NGOs and certain regional governments. This compelled the Kabul government to take a stand in this regard. Therefore, these two incidents within a short period of time have caused tensions between Iran and Afghanistan, and as the two sides insist on their positions and narratives of the incident, the crisis remains unresolved.

Meanwhile, although some people are trying to fish in troubled waters by provoking some foreign countries as these people organized protests, albeit limited, in front of the Iranian embassy in Kabul, but there is no doubt that there are problems with the status of Afghan citizens in Iran, something that cannot be denied. Therefore, these problems must be resolved as soon as possible and their traffic to Iran must be legalized.

Therefore, given the long-standing relations between Iran and Afghanistan, it is necessary to resolve such tensions more quickly, because the two nations have cultural, linguistic, religious and historical commonalities. The best solution is to form a committee of the Iranian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and a joint group including the Afghan side to look into the matter.

The second group is people who enter Iran as workforce, and these people must also be organized. Since the occupation of Afghanistan by the former Soviet Union, Iran has hosted a large number of Afghans, and nearly three million Afghans have entered Iran over the years.

Therefore, given the history of bilateral relations and the fact that the Islamic Republic has always welcomed Afghan citizens in the past few decades, the two countries should work to resolve the problems and not allow the relations between the Afghan and Iranian nations to deteriorate.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST CONTENT

An Analysis of the Establishment of a Joint Arab Command in Kuwait

SCFR Online – Opinion: The establishment of a joint Arab command in Kuwait will contribute to sustainable Persian Gulf security only when it distances itself from dependence on America and is based on pursuing the participation and cooperation of all regional countries.

The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran

SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.

Strategic Consequences of the US Midterm Elections

SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the US midterm elections, by exposing the political and economic costs of the war against Iran, will affect the scope of maneuver of the Trump administration and Washington’s regional calculations.

A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting

SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.

Loading

Últimas publicaciones

An Analysis of the Establishment of a Joint Arab Command in Kuwait

SCFR Online – Opinion: The establishment of a joint Arab command in Kuwait will contribute to sustainable Persian Gulf security only when it distances itself from dependence on America and is based on pursuing the participation and cooperation of all regional countries.

The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran

SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.

Strategic Consequences of the US Midterm Elections

SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the US midterm elections, by exposing the political and economic costs of the war against Iran, will affect the scope of maneuver of the Trump administration and Washington’s regional calculations.

A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting

SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

An Analysis of the Establishment of a Joint Arab Command in Kuwait

SCFR Online – Opinion: The establishment of a joint Arab command in Kuwait will contribute to sustainable Persian Gulf security only when it distances itself from dependence on America and is based on pursuing the participation and cooperation of all regional countries.

The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran

SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.

Strategic Consequences of the US Midterm Elections

SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the US midterm elections, by exposing the political and economic costs of the war against Iran, will affect the scope of maneuver of the Trump administration and Washington’s regional calculations.

A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting

SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

An Analysis of the Establishment of a Joint Arab Command in Kuwait

SCFR Online – Opinion: The establishment of a joint Arab command in Kuwait will contribute to sustainable Persian Gulf security only when it distances itself from dependence on America and is based on pursuing the participation and cooperation of all regional countries.

The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran

SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.

Strategic Consequences of the US Midterm Elections

SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the US midterm elections, by exposing the political and economic costs of the war against Iran, will affect the scope of maneuver of the Trump administration and Washington’s regional calculations.

A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting

SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.

Loading

DERNIER CONTENU

An Analysis of the Establishment of a Joint Arab Command in Kuwait

SCFR Online – Opinion: The establishment of a joint Arab command in Kuwait will contribute to sustainable Persian Gulf security only when it distances itself from dependence on America and is based on pursuing the participation and cooperation of all regional countries.

The Impact of the Political Deadlock in the Israeli Regime on the Future of the War Against Iran

SCFR Online – Opinion: The deadlock in forming a new cabinet in the Israeli regime, simultaneous with the continuation of the atmosphere of military confrontation between Iran and the United States and the relevant diplomatic process, is considered an important variable in West Asian security calculations. Although the political developments of the Israeli regime alone do not determine the fate of the war, they can affect the timing, level, and manner of the continuation of military confrontation.

Strategic Consequences of the US Midterm Elections

SCFR Online – Opinion: The results of the US midterm elections, by exposing the political and economic costs of the war against Iran, will affect the scope of maneuver of the Trump administration and Washington’s regional calculations.

A Reflection on the Capacities and Challenges of the Istanbul Ministerial Meeting

SCFR Online – Opinion: The meeting of the foreign ministers of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt in Istanbul has provided an opportunity for diplomatic coordination regarding West Asian crises, but its success will depend on the participation of key actors and the transformation of consultations into practical measures.

Loading